How Gutters Differ on Northshore Homes in Mandeville, Covington and Madisonville

Published

Across Lake Pontchartrain from New Orleans, the gutter questions change. Most Northshore houses are far newer than those on the south shore, the rain still peaks in midsummer, and two of its towns have written down exactly which gutters belong on their historic buildings.

A gutter on a Northshore home faces the same heavy rain as one in New Orleans, but the houses, the rules and the choices around them are not the same.

That matters if you live in Mandeville, Covington or Madisonville. A style that suits a 2000s subdivision home may not be what the local design guidelines expect on a house in a historic district.

At Big Easy Gutters, we install, repair and replace gutters for homes and businesses across the New Orleans area, and Mandeville, Covington and Madisonville are all part of our service area.

If you are planning gutter work on a Northshore property, contact us to set up a free estimate.

What Sets Northshore Homes Apart From the South Shore

Three things shape a Northshore gutter job: the age of the housing, the rain pattern and the local design rules. Each one points the decision in a slightly different direction.

Newer Houses Across St. Tammany Parish

The U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey for 2020 to 2024 puts the median home in St. Tammany Parish at a build year of 1995. In Orleans Parish, the median is 1960.

The gap is widest among the oldest homes. Only about 1.6 percent of St. Tammany’s housing units were built in 1939 or earlier, compared with about 31.4 percent in Orleans Parish. The single largest group in St. Tammany, about 23.6 percent, went up between 2000 and 2009.

So most Northshore gutter jobs are on houses with modern eaves and fascia, where a standard hanging gutter fits without fuss. The exceptions are the older blocks in the historic districts, and that is where the written guidance below comes in.

Summer Rain at the Slidell Station

NOAA’s 1991 to 2020 climate normals for Slidell Airport average 61.88 inches of rain a year. The same record counts an average of 19.9 days a year with an inch of rain or more.

The monthly pattern is what stands out. July is the wettest month at 7.25 inches, followed by August at 6.96 inches, while October is the driest at 3.72 inches. The City of Covington describes its own annual rainfall as averaging over 60 inches but varying widely.

For a gutter, that means the hardest test arrives in midsummer. A trough that is still holding spring leaves has less room for that water, which is why debris matters so much, as we cover in our post on what tree debris does to gutters.

Two Historic Districts With Written Gutter Guidance

Mandeville and Covington each have a historic district commission, and each publishes design guidelines that name gutters directly. That gives homeowners a written answer on style before the work starts.

Gutter Guidance in Old Mandeville’s Historic Preservation District

Mandeville’s Historic Preservation District was created by city ordinance in 2013. Its design guidelines, adopted on September 19, 2019, include a full section on roofs, chimneys and gutters.

Where the District Begins and Ends

The guidelines set the district’s boundaries at the center lines of Galvez Street, Florida Street, Jackson Avenue and Lake Pontchartrain. A 2015 survey counted about 1,520 parcels inside it, including 597 historic-age resources from 1965 or earlier.

The district’s rules apply to exterior architectural features on buildings classified as Contributing, Significant or Landmark. The guidelines also state that district regulations do not prevent routine maintenance or repairs, and they list ordinary repairs and maintenance among the non-substantive changes.

Approval and permits run side by side. A Certificate of Appropriateness can be handled at the same time as a building permit application, but it does not replace the permit. The city’s Director of Planning is the district’s administrator, so that office is the place to ask before replacing gutters on a listed house.

Half Round First, With K-Style and Ogee as Options

White half-round gutter with round downspout and hangers along a brick houseThe guidelines are clear about style. New gutters should be half round, which the document calls the most historically accurate design, and they note that “K” or ogee design gutters of aluminum are also approvable.

For buildings dating from or influenced by designs from the 1940s or later, ogee gutters are listed as appropriate. Our half-round gutters page shows that profile, and our K-style rain gutters page shows the more common modern shape.

A bit of history explains the preference. The guidelines note that most of Mandeville’s 19th and early 20th century homes were not originally built with any gutter at all. By the late 19th century, wood and metal gutters became more widespread, and half-round designs were widely used.

Box Gutters, Hardware and Color

More ornate older homes sometimes had box gutters, which the guidelines describe as metal-lined wooden boxes at the eaves, lined with lead, tin or copper. The guidance is to preserve original box gutters and keep them clear.

For new work, the guidelines call for minimal hardware to avoid damaging historic fabric, downspouts placed behind porch columns and building corners where possible, and gutter colors that blend with the home’s main body or trim. Conductor heads are encouraged where appropriate.

If your older home has copper lining or copper trim, the green marks it can leave on light surfaces are explained in our guide to reading the streaks on a New Orleans home.

Gutter Guidance in Covington’s Historic District

Covington created its Historic District Commission in 1989. The commission reviews certificate of appropriateness applications for construction, material alteration, demolition or relocation of any building, structure or appurtenance in the district.

The Commission and Its Certificates

On the city’s Historic District Commission page, the commission is described as the official body that reviews proposals for exterior changes to properties within the historic district. It issues Certificates of Appropriateness for approved proposals.

The city also links its historic preservation design guidelines from that page. They were prepared in 2012 by Thomason and Associates, a preservation planning firm, and they include a section on gutters and downspouts.

If you are not sure whether your property sits inside the Covington Historic District, ask the city’s Planning and Zoning department before the work is scheduled. It is far easier to settle the style first than to change a gutter after it goes up.

Hanging Gutter Styles for Older and Newer Buildings

Covington’s guidelines strongly recommend using and maintaining gutters, downspouts and splash blocks. They say to retain existing boxed or built-in gutters and to repair them where possible, rather than replacing them with new gutters.

When new gutters are needed, the guidelines name half round as the most appropriate hanging design. Ogee gutters are also listed as appropriate on buildings dating from, or influenced by, designs from the 1940s or later. The maintenance appendix adds that half-round gutters and round downspouts are preferable to corrugated designs.

Downspouts on the Least Public Side

The guidelines ask for downspouts to be located away from architectural features and on the least public side of the building. On a corner lot or a house with a wraparound porch, that takes some planning, because the downspout has to sit where the gutter can actually empty.

The residential roofs section adds a maintenance note too. It says to keep gutters and downspouts free of debris, keep them maintained, and repair leaking roofs, gutters and downspouts.

How Gutter Styles Line Up Across the Northshore

Outside the two historic districts, the choice comes down to the house and the homeowner. Louisiana’s statewide minimum code for homes has been the 2021 International Residential Code since January 1, 2023, as Covington’s permit page also lists.

Here is how the common gutter types compare against the local guidance:

Gutter Type What the Local Guidance Says Best For
Half round Preferred hanging design in both Mandeville and Covington Older homes in either historic district
Ogee Appropriate on buildings from or influenced by the 1940s or later Mid-century houses inside the districts
K-style aluminum Approvable in Mandeville’s district; half round is preferred Newer homes outside the districts
Box or built-in Retain and repair originals rather than replace them Historic homes that already have them

Madisonville and Homes Outside the Districts

Most Northshore homes, including most of Madisonville, sit outside the two historic districts described above. For them, the gutter choice is mostly about the roofline, the look you want and how the water needs to leave the roof.

That freedom matters on newer houses with long, straight eaves, where the choice is mostly about looks and capacity. On an older cottage outside a district, half round can still be the better match for the house, even when nobody requires it.

Older Houses That Never Had Gutters

Some older Northshore homes were built without gutters and had them added later, which the Mandeville guidelines say was true of most of the town’s 19th and early 20th century homes. On those houses, the hangers, outlets and downspouts can be among the newest parts of the exterior.

That makes the details more visible. A downspout run across a front porch or a heavy row of hangers on a narrow fascia can look out of place, which is exactly what both towns’ guidelines try to prevent. Our guide to how gutters are fitted on historic New Orleans homes covers the same balance on the south shore.

What This Means for Your Northshore Home

If your house sits in Old Mandeville or Covington’s historic district, start with the design guidelines and the city office before choosing a gutter. Half round is the safe first choice in both, and original box gutters are meant to be kept and repaired.

If your house is newer, as half of St. Tammany’s homes are (built in 1995 or later), you have more room to choose. Plan for the July and August storms, and put the downspouts where they do the most good and draw the least attention.

Inside or outside a district, keep the downspouts and outlets in the plan from the start. Both towns’ guidelines give as much attention to where the downspouts go as to the gutter profile itself.

At Big Easy Gutters, our free estimate starts with a project specialist coming to your home to look over the property with you. Our Mandeville gutter services and Covington gutter services pages show what we offer in each town.

Bring any letter or approval from the city if your home is in a historic district, so the gutter can be planned around it.

To schedule your Northshore estimate, call us at (504) 688-3797.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need approval to replace gutters in Old Mandeville?

It depends on the building. Mandeville’s district rules apply to exterior features on buildings classified as Contributing, Significant or Landmark, and the guidelines say routine maintenance and repairs are not prevented. For replacement gutters on a listed house, check with the city’s Director of Planning, who administers the district, because a Certificate of Appropriateness does not replace the building permit.

Which gutter style does Mandeville prefer?

Half round. Mandeville’s 2019 Design Guidelines say new gutters should be half-round designs because they are the most historically accurate. Ogee gutters are also listed as appropriate for buildings from or influenced by the 1940s or later.

Are K-style aluminum gutters allowed in Mandeville’s historic district?

The guidelines say “K” or ogee design gutters of aluminum are also approvable. They still state a preference for half round, so K-style is an option, but not the first choice, inside the district.

Does Covington have a historic district commission?

Yes. The City of Covington created the Covington Historic District Commission in 1989. It reviews proposals for exterior changes to properties in the historic district and issues Certificates of Appropriateness for approved proposals.

Which gutters do Covington’s historic guidelines recommend?

Covington’s 2012 guidelines name half round as the most appropriate hanging gutter, with ogee also appropriate on buildings from the 1940s or later. They also ask owners to retain and repair existing boxed or built-in gutters and to place downspouts on the least public side of the building.

How much rain falls on the Northshore?

NOAA’s 1991 to 2020 normals for Slidell Airport average 61.88 inches a year, with about 19.9 days of an inch or more. July is the wettest month at 7.25 inches. Covington’s own flood page describes annual rainfall averaging over 60 inches.

Are Northshore homes newer than homes in New Orleans?

On average, yes. The Census Bureau’s 2020 to 2024 American Community Survey puts the median build year at 1995 in St. Tammany Parish and 1960 in Orleans Parish. Only about 1.6 percent of St. Tammany homes were built in 1939 or earlier.

Which building code applies to homes in Madisonville and the rest of the Northshore?

Louisiana’s statewide minimum code for homes is the 2021 International Residential Code, in effect since January 1, 2023. Local historic districts, like those in Mandeville and Covington, add their own design guidelines on top of it.


Ready to talk about your gutters?

CallFree Estimates